September 26, 2002
FAMILY PORTRAIT: Lloyd Singh, his wife Wanda and two children Lolda, 12, and Vidal, 9.
Joy Arjune.
DPP recalls
deadly attack on bar
DIRECTOR of Public
Prosecution (DPP), Mr. Denis Hanomansngh was yesterday still trying to come to
grips with the "scare of his life" on Wednesday night.
Hanomansingh
was among several persons wounded when gunmen opened fire on patrons at the
`Nathoo' bar, Lamaha and Pike Streets, Kitty, Georgetown, around 18:45
hrs.
The DPP who
was wounded in the shoulder, but has not been hospitalised, told the Chronicle
that he lived through scary times in Northern Ireland as a student "but nothing
has scared me more than last night (Wednesday night)."
He said he had
gone home during the afternoon with the intention of exercising on his
treadmill, but found there was an electricity blackout.
He said he
subsequently left home about 17:00 hrs for the bar to "pass the time away
gaffing, until I suspect the electricity had returned."
He remembered
standing behind the counter, facing the roadway and chatting with deceased Gavin
Narine when he observed a man walk into the bar and immediately open
fire.
Hanomansingh
said his immediate reaction on hearing the first volley was to hit the ground
where he remained until the shooting subsided.
He said he
then overheard Policeman Corporal Balram asking "Barran, yuh alright?" and it
was only then that he got up.
The DPP said
that as he came out of the bar and around to the customer area, "all I saw were
bodies and blood everywhere."
He remembered
that in addition Narine, another of the dead men
Lloyd Singh, and Beharry
Dookie, also called ` Nathoo', the proprietor, were with others in the customer
area.
The DPP said
he and Nathoo were transported by friends to St Joseph's Mercy Hospital where he
received medical attention and was sent away.
Hanomansingh
said that about four weeks ago, he was advised by a lawyer to be "careful" as he
had received information from a client that the DPP was reportedly on the "hit
list".
The DPP said
he had requested a Tactical Services Unit (TSC) guard but was told none was
available.
He reiterated
that as a result of Wednesday night's narrow escape, he feels his life is even
more threatened adding, the "fear is still there".
Asked if he
would accept security if his request is reviewed, the DPP said, "if they offer,
I will accept."
On whether he
had recruited Trinidad Senior Counsel, Rangee Dolsingh to function as Lead
Prosecutor in the ongoing Mark Benschop/Phillip Bynoe treason case being heard
before Magistrate Chandra Sohan, the DPP said after the charge was instituted he
"has not intervened, nor hired any prosecutor...none was hired by the
DPP."
According to
him, a formal request was made to the DPP's office regarding having people to
prosecute and the request was granted.
Hanomansingh
pointed out that such a request is a norm as no expense is incurred to the DPP's
office.
Trinidadian Special
Prosecutor could have been in bar with DPP
TRINIDADIAN-born Senior
Counsel, Rangee Dolsingh, the Special Prosecutor recruited to lead the State's
case in the ongoing historic treason case here, considers himself lucky to have
escaped being a likely victim in Wednesday night's attack in
Georgetown.
"I have been
to Guyana many times...I would have been in Guyana now, maybe at the same
location, but by God's grace I got away," Dolsingh told the Chronicle
yesterday.
He explained
that he was due in Guyana last week and most likely may have been at the same
location with local Director of Public Prosecution (DPP), Denis
Hanomansingh.
In a brutal
attack early Wednesday night, four persons were killed and at least 10 wounded,
among them, Hanomansingh, at Nathoo's Bar at Pike and Lamaha Streets,
Kitty.
The DPP was
rushed to a city hospital after being shot in the shoulder, but his injury was
not considered life-threatening. He was treated and released.
Dolsingh said
he was approached indirectly and accepted an offer to lead the prosecution's
case in the treason trial involving Mark Benschop and wanted fugitive Phillip
Bynoe.
He was
scheduled to be here in the last week but was suffering from chest pains and had
to be hospitalised.
And when made
fresh arrangements were made for him to arrive in the country for the start of
the Preliminary Inquiry (PI) on Monday, he contracted a viral infection and on
the advice of his doctor, again had to delay his travel.
The
British-trained, former Deputy Director of Public Prosecution (DPP) in Trinidad
who went into pre-retirement about a week ago, said he is not deterred by
Wednesday night's attack providing his security is guaranteed .
Reached by the
Chronicle in Trinidad, Dolsingh said, "I am not deterred, providing my security
is guaranteed. I see my participation in the case as a challenge and nothing
will hinder me seeing that justice is done, one way or the other, for the State
or the accused. I have to act as the man of justice."
The Senior
Counsel, who said he has applied to the Trinidad Government for permission to
practice during his pre-retirement, said he accepted the challenge because he is
confident that with him being "civic, independent, non-political, non-racial and
with an independent mind, (he) will see justice is done and not pursue
anyone."
"When I
accepted the job I thought that as an outsider I would not be
molested."
He noted too,
that his plan to travel secretly to Guyana last weekend was blown when a
Trinidad newspaper reported that he had arrived in this country since
Sunday.
Remarking that
he has been apprised of the alleged threats made against Chief Magistrate,
Juliet Holder-Allen's life, Dolsingh declared, "chances are I may have been at
the same location with the DPP".
It was on this
note the Trinidadian Senior Counsel posited, "I am not deterred in any way,
provided my security is guaranteed...."
Dolsingh says
he hopes to be in the country in another four to five days, adding, "I would
allow things to settle first."
The Senior
Counsel recalled that in 1998 he appeared against Attorney General Doodnauth
Singh in an extradition case involving Guyanese seaman, Allan Henry, who had
killed a British national on a yacht in Trinidad.
Henry,
Dolsingh said, was nabbed at Wakenaam island, in Essequibo and he, representing
the State of Trinidad, was successful in having the fugitive extradited to
Trinidad where he was subsequently tried, convicted and sentenced to
death.
However, after
being on death row for five years awaiting execution, the Trinidad Government
commuted Henry's death sentence to one of life imprisonment.
MOURNING: mother of Lloyd and Joy, Ms. Bibi Singh.